Skip to Content

Extra Thick and Regular Toilet Wax Rings: Comparison Guide

Toilet Wax Rings, When it comes to plumbing, there are so many things that can go wrong. One of the most common problems is a leaky toilet or a toilet that leaks around the base. While this can be caused by a number of things, most often it is due to a faulty or damaged, or old wax ring.

Fortunately, there are many different types of wax rings on the market to help resolve the issue- although it can be a little difficult to know which one to choose for your toilet.

Two common types of wax rings that you’ll come across are the extra thick wax ring, which is designed for toilets that see a lot of use, and Regular wax rings, which are also available but are normally used for toilets that are not used as often.

So in this blog post, we’ll compare extra thick wax rings and regular wax rings to help you decide the best option for your toilet.

Extra Thick Wax Ring vs Regular: Overview

Toilet Wax Rings

At this point, you probably already know that a leaky toilet means you need to replace the wax ring. However, what many people don’t understand is that different types of wax rings are basically meant for varied purposes; and the same case applies to regular and extra thick wax rings.

While these two options have their pros and cons, it’s important to know the difference before you make a decision. Otherwise, you might be wondering whether you should go with an extra thick wax ring or a regular wax ring.

Extra Thick Wax Ring vs Regular: How Do They Compare?

Note that the main purpose of wax rings is to seal the connection between the toilet and the sewer line. As the name suggests, they are usually made of wax or rubber, and over time they can break down and become less effective- which brings about the need to choose a high-quality wax ring that will last.

On a basic level, an extra thick wax ring is designed to provide a better seal than a regular wax ring. In fact, this type of wax ring is often used in situations where there is a significant amount of water pressure, such as in a shower. Extra thick wax rings are also often used in commercial applications, such as in restaurants.

Wax Ring vs Regular

One main aspect that makes extra thick wax rings stand out is that they provide an additional layer of protection against leaks as they are generally made of thicker and denser materials, which makes them more effective at sealing the gap between the flange and the toilet bowl.

On the flip side though, these types of wax rings can be more difficult to install, and if your toilet isn’t properly aligned, an extra thick wax ring may not fit properly, which can actually cause leaks. They are not the easiest to install, and they may not fit all types of toilets.

On the other hand, regular wax rings are less expensive and easier to install, but they don’t provide as strong of a seal. They’re generally considered an ideal option for infrequently used toilets or toilets that are in good condition and don’t need as much support.

In simple words, extra thick wax rings are ideal for toilets that are used frequently, as they provide a stronger seal that won’t break down as quickly. Meanwhile, regular wax rings are generally easier to install, and although they’re less expensive, they do not provide as strong of a seal.

Extra Thick Wax Ring vs Regular: which one is Better for Your Toilet?

Well, the answer depends on how frequently your toilet is used. If you have a toilet that is used frequently, an extra thick wax ring may be a good option. This type of wax ring is designed to withstand more use and will last longer.

Regular wax rings, on the other hand, are also great but are meant for toilets that are not used as often. These wax rings are less expensive, easier to install, and can still provide a good seal.

Why Extra Thick Wax Ring Might be a Better Option

Toilet Wax Rings

If you’re in the market for a new wax ring for your toilet, you may be wondering if it’s worth it to get the extra thick variety. After all, it does cost a bit more than the regular wax ring. But is it worth the extra expense? Well, it depends on your needs and budget.

Extra thick wax rings are generally more reliable compared to the regular option because they provide a better seal. When you install a toilet, you need to create a seal between the toilet and the floor. Fortunately, this seal prevents water from leaking out and ruining your floor.

Also, a good seal is important because it keeps your bathroom clean and dry. Note that water that leaks out from underneath a toilet can cause all sorts of problems, like mold and mildew, and all of these can also ruin your flooring.

Despite their high cost, extra thick wax rings are a great choice for anyone who wants to avoid leaks. They provide a better seal than standard wax rings, and they are less likely to break down over time. If you’re looking for a reliable way to keep your toilet sealed, an extra thick wax ring is your best bet.

The Bottom Line

No doubts that toilet leaks are one of the most frustrating plumbing issues. No matter which type of wax ring you choose, be sure to keep your needs in mind.

An extra thick wax ring provides a better seal than a standard wax ring, but it is significantly more expensive and harder to install. This means that you’re less likely to have water leaks, and your bathroom will stay clean and dry. If you’re looking for the best way to create a seal between your toilet and the floor, an extra thick wax ring is the way to go.

That said, if your toilet is not used so frequently, a regular wax ring can be a great option. It is easier to install than the thick type and is less expensive.