Skip to Content

Simonton Windows vs Milgard

When shopping for windows, you should choose long-lasting and energy-efficient ones, allowing you to maintain a steady temperature within your home and keep the interior cool in the summer and warm in the winter. These characteristics can be found in both Simonton and Milgard. Both also protect from

harsh elements, insects, weather, and dampness.

In this article, we’ll compare the two brands so you can decide which is best for you.

Simonton Windows vs Milgard: Overview

Overview of Simonton Windows

Simonton is a brand that manufactures high-quality, energy-efficient windows and doors for new construction and replacement. It is located in Pennsboro, West Virginia, and was created in 1946 by Fred and Sybil Simonton.

Ply Gem, a maker of external building products that include doors, windows, railing, siding, fence, and stone veneer products, produces Simonton Windows.

Simonton windows are long-lasting and energy-efficient windows that come in 9 different styles. The styles include single-hung windows, double-hung windows, casement windows, slider windows, bay or bow windows, awning windows, geometric windows, picture windows, and garden windows.

Simonton Windows come in 12 different series. These include Simonton Reflections 5050, Simonton Reflections 5500, Simonton Impressions, Simonton Asure, Simonton StormBreaker Plus, Brickmould 600, Simonton ProFinish, Brickmould 300, Simonton ProFinish, Simonton ProFinish Builder, Simonton ProFinish Contractor, Madeira, DaylightMax, and Verona.

The exterior color options for these windows include brick, black, cream, chocolate, pine, white,  driftwood, and tan, while driftwood, oak, tan, antique cherry, maple, and white are the unique woodgrain interior color options. The windows also feature several hardware finish options: driftwood, oil-rubbed bronze, polished brass, dark bronze, nickel, and tan.

Simonton Windows also provides four grid styles: 5/8′′ Flat, 3/4′′ Sculptured, 3/4′′ Sculptured Brass, and 1′′ Sculptured, as well as seven grid patterns: Double perimeter, Diamond (flat only), Prairie, Colonial, Double Prairie, Perimeter, and Victorian (flat only).

Overview of Milgard

Milgard Windows is made by Milgard Manufacturing, Inc, a company specializing in custom windows and doors. Maurice Milgard, Jr. and Gary Milgard formed the company in 1958, and it is based in Tacoma, Washington.

Milgard manufactures energy-efficient new construction and replacement windows in three different window frame materials: vinyl, aluminum, and fiberglass.

Milgard features seven window styles. The styles include horizontal slider windows, radius windows, double horizontal slider windows, hung windows, single hung windows, casement windows, picture windows, bay & bow windows, awning windows, and specialty windows.

The windows series include Trinsic Series | V300, Tuscany Series | V400, Ultra Series | C650, Style Line Series | V250, and Thermally Improved Aluminum | A250.

White and tan are offered as interior colors for both the Tuscany Series | V400 and the Style Line Series | V250, while fog, sand, classic brown, ivory, silver, espresso, and bronze are exterior colors.

The Trinsic Series | V300 is available in three interior colors: tan, white, and back, as well as ten exterior colors: tan, white, ivory, sand, silver, fog, espresso, classic brown, bronze, and black.

The inside colors of the Ultra Series | C650 are harmony, white, bark, and black bean, while the exterior colors are harmony, frost, black bean, and bark. Clear anodized and bronze anodized are the inside and exterior colors offered for the Thermally Improved Aluminum | A250 Series.

The grid variations available for these windows are sculptured grid, flat grid, simulated divided lite (SDL), and 2-1/4′′ check rail.

Simonton vs. Milgard: Material Comparison

Engineered windows from Simonton Windows come in four different frame materials: vinyl, aluminum, aluminum-clad wood, and wood composite. On the other hand, Milgard windows come in three different frame materials: vinyl, fiberglass, and aluminum.

Simonton vs. Milgard: Energy Efficiency Comparison

Simonton Windows’ window products are entirely ENERGY STAR certified, indicating that they are high-quality and environmentally friendly. They offer advantages like reduced heat transmission and improved insulation, making them ideal energy-efficient windows for residential and commercial applications.

Standard Argon-gas-filled windows with Low-emissivity glass are also available from Simonton Windows, which help limit the amount of UV and infrared radiation that goes through while allowing plenty of natural light to enter your home. Low-E glass also aids in the regulation and maintenance of a comfortable indoor temperature.

Additionally, their window product lines include triple-pane windows with ProSolar Low-E glass and three layers of silver to boost insulation and prevent fading of the window materials. It also saves money on heating and cooling while keeping people warm and comfortable inside.

Milgard window products include glass with dual and triple glazing that helps insulate the inside, reduce energy consumption during the winter, and heat during the summer.  Also, argon gas is between the panes of their windows, which improves thermal insulation.

SunCoat and SunCoatMAX Low-E Glass Coatings are applied to one side or surface of the glass to help maintain a consistent temperature, improve energy efficiency, and improve the thermal performance of the windows by reflecting heat to the exterior part of the house during the summer and keeping it inside during the winter.

Milgard also includes EdgeGardMAX Spacers, which are placed between two panes at the proper distance to offer insulation by blocking heat transfer and decreasing condensation on the windows.

Simonton vs. Milgard: Price Comparison

Simonton Windows’ average industry pricing ranges from $200 to $1200 per window and $265 to $1,500 per window installed.

Milgard Windows have an average industry price range of $170 to $1,890 per window and $325 to $2,650 per installed window.

Simonton vs. Milgard: Warranty Comparison

R Simonton Windows provides a 10-year limited warranty for multi-resident and commercial warranty holders and a double limited warranty for residential warranty holders.

The Double-Lifetime Limited Warranty covers vinyl components, hardware, and screens. The original warranty holder may also transfer it to a subsequent owner.

For commercial or multi-resident warranty holders, the Lifetime Limited Warranty covers laminated glass, vinyl components, hardware glass, and factory-applied exterior coatings for three years. Except for the 3-year Factory-Applied Exterior Coating Limited Warranty, the Lifetime Limited Warranty is transferable within the 10-year warranty period.

The vinyl and hardware components, screens, and glass goods are covered by both the Double-Lifetime Limited Warranty and the Lifetime Limited Warranty. Furthermore, the warranty does not cover the costs of removal, installation, repair, or labor.

Milgard replacement window products come with two warranties: a full lifetime warranty and a lifetime limited warranty.

Tuscany Series | V400 and Trinsic Series | V3001 have a Full Lifetime Warranty, while Style Line Series | V2502, Ultra Series | C650, and Thermally Improved Aluminum | A250 have a Lifetime Limited Warranty.

Milgard Windows also provides a ten-year limited warranty to all owners of the covered product.

Simonton Vs. Milgard: Final Take

Both Simonton and Milgard Windows manufacture energy-efficient new construction and replacement windows that are high-performing and long-lasting. Both manufacturers provide window solutions cheaply that meet the customer’s needs and budget, allowing for cost-effective and convenient replacement window projects.

Simonton is an excellent window brand if you want high-quality windows with various frame materials, product lines, and decorative options.